El Cantarito: Michigan City
336 Dunes Plaza, Michigan City, IN 46360
An unassuming store front in a strip mall conceals our favorite Mexican restaurant, El Cantarito. We have a date night every Tuesday and this is one of our go-to spots for our date night meal. The atmosphere includes fin murals on the walls with a nice mix of booths and tables. We almost always request a booth and have never had to wait for one, even when the restaurant is busy.
Tonight I ordered my favorite, Carne Asada, cooked as rare as possible. One of the problems I often have with this dish is that it often tastes as if it’s been seasoned with beef bullion. This NOT the case at El Cantarito. Their Carne Asada has the most amazing, fresh flavor I’ve ever had and I have trouble remembering that I should take half of it home for the next day. There is a lot of food included with the meal and it makes great leftovers. Tonight the flavor was just slightly lacking its usual intensity and I found it a bit easier to save half for later. My fiancé also enjoys the Carne Asada (although he didn’t have it tonight) because there is no dairy included on the plate, so he doesn’t have to mention his allergy when ordering. The other thing I appreciate about the Carne Asada here is that when I order it rare, it actually arrives rare, which is not easy to do with such a thin cut of meat. I also appreciate the accompaniment of real beans instead of the typical refried beans. The texture of whole beans pairs a little better with the other ingredients when building the tortilla.
Tonight my fiancé ordered a favorite, the Chicken Fajitas. While the fajitas here don’t normally come with cheese or sour cream, he does still have to mention “no dairy” because they do come with refried beans, which are typically topped with a sprinkling of queso blanco, white cheese. He must have been very hungry tonight because he usually has some leftovers to bring home too, but tonight he finished the whole dish. He said the flavor was really good and everything tasted fresh. He didn’t want to ruin it with reheating.
We have long loved El Cantarito and this visit didn’t change that one bit. We will likely be back again at least once within the month. Perhaps I’ll use that opportunity to review one of my other favorite dishes.